Individuality and conformity, these are conflicting values. The
question is, how much individualism is good and how much conformity is good? Mass
produced items tend to show conformity in our culture in spite of the fact that
individual freedom of choice is highly valued in our society. The essay “Slaves
of Fashion” shows that people want to be a part of this group of fitting in and
there is a subconscious battle of being the best and showing we are elite. In our culture items could show
individuality, but we are often conformist because group identity shows as most
important.
All people really need are utensils,
clothing, tools, space for living, space for religious expression, and space
for social interaction. So why do we feel like we have to “keep up with the
Jones”? Why do we conform to fit this social status even when we don’t always have
the financial means to do so? All people,
regardless of culture, have a need for individual identity and for group identity.
Some cultures stress individuality more and others stress group identity more.
These identity values are expressed symbolically in the design of utensils,
clothing, houses, places of worship, and public spaces. We know that
meeting human needs consumes resources, but we also value caring for
resources. In the essay “Women Shopping and Women Sweat Shopping” how much
do we value these mass produced items if the people making them suffer because of
the high demand needed to be produced? When we are trying so hard to have our
own identities but still do not pay attention to the ethics behind the items
being produced, are we still conforming to the same ethical behaviors as
others. It is difficult to always consider where and how certain items were
made and the people making them, but by not ever having a moral compass is
allowing this to continue. I personal try to buy flax leather or fur and try to
shop at stores that do not condone sweatshops and produce items ethically.
As members of the human race it is our
privilege and obligation to do what we can to improve the conditions in which
people live. The arguments and the
differences of opinions come when we start to make consumer selections to meet
these needs. As soon as we do something or make something to fulfill our basic
needs we are saying something about our values and our beliefs. What are the
values related to our basic needs that are played out in our everyday decisions?
When we discuss values we find a continuum of opinions and arguments. But
should the arguments be between individuality and conformity or with our
culture and these companies producing these items?
No comments:
Post a Comment